Centering Love in the Staff Appraisal Process

As our office gathered to consider ways that love shows up in our work, the appraisal process was likely the last thing that most people were thinking about. But for Thomas Bryant, our Associate Director of Finance and Operations, it was a top priority. "This is something I am passionate about. Rethinking how we do appraisals at the Office of Child Development to move away from this just being a bureaucratic process to something that is part of our culture and aligned with our values." An appraisal process grounded in love is one that allows us to take down our defensiveness and be open to feedback. It is one that sees the power dynamic between supervisor and staff, and makes room for shared decision-making and bidirectional accountability.

The officewide conversation sparked new ways to see the process and the connection to love became clearer:

“For me, the appraisal process helps to build relationships. It helps me show my team that I care about the work we are doing and helping it grow. I give feedback because I notice and I care.” 

-Dr. Rhonda Hall, Director of Family & Community Partnerships

Thomas asked us to consider, how we want to hold each other accountable. How do we create a space where people can hold hard conversations honestly and have space to grow? “Your supervisor is not the only person who makes all the decisions, we should all be making the decisions together.” To frame this conversation about accountability, we used our office's co-created definition of love:

Love is seeing & embracing humanity in all people, & being committed to achieving justice for everyone, unconditionally. This kind of love challenges, corrects, acknowledges power, & makes space for all. It is because of love, that we hold each other accountable when harm is done.

We each have a responsibility to prepare ourselves to be in a relationship with our supervisors that is open to loving accountability. Thomas asked us to consider whether we each felt open to recieving feedback. He said, "When I get feedback, my first reaction is defensiveness. I have to reframe what I hear. I have to take down my defensive wall. That doesn’t mean you can’t have a conversation about it. But being open is this first step. Feedback needs to be frequent, not necessarily formal, but consistent. It builds a relationship. That is on everyone. Invite feedback from your supervisor. Know your supervisor and your staff. If they need time to process, maybe send questions first and take time to debrief. That was a huge "A ha" for me. That changed my way of supervising and being supervised."  

Love also frames the way feedback is offered. The language used can make a big difference in how feedback is taken. It can feel less like criticism and more like empowering you to grow. We need to continually practice that. What can regular progess conversations that are more specific to what you are doing, look like? The more these happen, the stronger our relationships will be. Ultimately, the goal is to build a culture of growth and honesty where end of the year appraisals are never something to worry about or be surprised by. They are ongoing conversations that, "challege, correct, acknowledge power, & make space for all."